Canada

How to Increase Profitability with Seeding Date Choice

Dow AgroSciences - March 05, 2001

Careful selection of seeding dates can give each crop type the best possible growing conditions, and thus increase total farm income. That's been demonstrated in a 4-year (1994 to 97) field experiment conducted at Swift Current. The study clearly showed a strong economic advantage for early seeding of all crop types, particularly oilseed and pulse crops. Early seeding does not add to production costs, but results in higher grain yields and farm income.

  • Early seeding (April 28 to May 6) increased seed yields by 3 to 22% for all crops compared to the traditional mid-May seeding (May 10 to May 15).

  • Delayed seeding (May 22 to May 31) decreased seed yields by 5 to 24% from the mid-May seeding date.

  • Among the crops tested, yellow mustard, argentine canola, sunflower, and canaryseed showed the greatest response to the early seeding, with yield increases of 12% or more over that obtained with mid-May seeding.

  • Delayed seeding caused the largest yield losses (16 to 23%) in oriental mustard, polish canola, yellow mustard, field pea, lentil, and canaryseed.

  • Wheat had the least response to seeding date.

Response of seed yield to seeding dates in southwestern Saskatchewan.

  Average Seed Yield‡ Yield increase over mid-May seeding
Crop type Apr 28 - May 6 May 10 - May 15 May 22 - May 31 Early Seeding Late Seeding
lb/ac %
Oilseed Argentina canola 1259 1116 1054 13 -6
Polish canola 1411 1331 1018 6 -24
Oriental mustard 1366 1357 1089 1 -20
Yellow mustard 1393 1134 947 22 -17
Sunflower 1241 1107 1125 12 2
Pulse Desi chickpea 2241 2125 1929 5 -9
Kabuli chickpea --- 1384 1295 --- -6
Field pea 2688 2608 2188 3 -16
Lentil 1598 1536 1179 4 -23
Cereal Canary Seed 1241 1125 884 10 -21
Spring Wheat 2599 2447 2322 6 -5

‡Average seed yield based on four years of data.


Profitability impacts
The study also estimated the impact of seeding date on gross income for the same crops, as grown on one section (640 acres). Total gross return was significantly affected by seeding date.

  • Early seeding of yellow mustard, argentine canola, and sunflower could capture more than $12,000 of additional income from one-section of land.

  • For most of the oilseed and pulse crops, later than normal (mid-May) seeding reduced gross income from $12,000 to $29,000, depending on the crops.

  • Wheat seeded between April 28 to May 31 resulted in the smallest changes (± $6500/640 ac) among the crop types.

Profitability of crops with different seeding dates in southwestern Saskatchewan.

  Gross income based on one section of land ($640/ac) ‡
Crop type May 10 - May 15 Change from normal seeding date
Normal-seeding date Early-seeding Late-seeding
$ per section
Oilseed Argentina canola 95,301 12,199 -5,337
Polish canola 113,599 6,862 -26,684
Oriental mustard 147,681 972 -29,148
Yellow mustard 130,649 29,833 -21,603
Sunflower 113,390 13,716 -1,829
Pulse Desi chickpea 163,226 8,916 -15,088
Kabuli chickpea 194,888 n/a -12,573
Field pea 133,507 4,115 -21,489
Lentil 186,773 7,601 -43,436
Cereal Canary Seed 79,213 8,173 -16,974
Spring Wheat 109,618 6,801 -5,601

‡Gross income was calculated based on 1999 on-farm prices described in Crop Planning Guide 1999 (Saskatchewan Agriculture and Food).

Seeding date does not have consistent effect on plant establishment for any crop, but it is wise to treat seed with recommended fungicides to ensure a good germination and emergence.


Source:
"Wise Seeding Date Decisions --- Discover the Hidden Value", Yantai Gan, Bob Zentner, and Brian McConkey, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada Semiarid Prairie Agricultural Research Centre Research Newsletter No.7 April 14, 2000.